Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Businesses > Intellectual property > Re: GPL propaga...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 10 of 34 Topic 2437 of 2452
Post > Topic >>

Re: GPL propaganda

by Hyman Rosen <hyrosen@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sep 25, 2008 at 11:20 PM

Rjack wrote:
> Try the doctrine of copyright misuse.

I can hear the soft mocking laughter of the judge when this
argument is presented and he notes that the GPL gives anyone
the right to run, read, and modify the program with absolutely
no restrictions.

> Try violation of 17 USC 301.

You cannot violate 301. That's the preemption section, and it
just takes copyright cases into federal law. Violation of the
GPL is copyright infringement, and it will be treated as such
by the federal courts.

> Try impossible contract terms.

It's a license, not a contract, and the terms are not only not
impossible, complying with them is extremely easy.
 




 34 Posts in Topic:
GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 19:17:19 
Re: GPL propaganda
Andrew Halliwell <spik  2008-09-26 01:26:33 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 19:38:23 
Re: GPL propaganda
RonB <ronb02nospam@[EM  2008-09-25 19:49:52 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 19:57:36 
Re: GPL propaganda
7 <website_has_email@[  2008-09-26 01:13:41 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 20:24:11 
Re: GPL propaganda
Andrew Halliwell <spik  2008-09-26 02:34:34 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 22:00:19 
Re: GPL propaganda
Hyman Rosen <hyrosen@[  2008-09-25 23:20:30 
Re: GPL propaganda
c.c.eiftj@[EMAIL PROTECTE  2008-09-26 21:29:41 
Re: GPL propaganda
7 <website_has_email@[  2008-09-26 01:09:05 
Re: GPL propaganda
JEDIDIAH <jedi@[EMAIL   2008-09-25 20:53:40 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 22:05:11 
Re: GPL propaganda
JEDIDIAH <jedi@[EMAIL   2008-09-26 08:13:30 
Re: GPL propaganda
Hyman Rosen <hyrosen@[  2008-09-25 22:58:16 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 22:15:48 
Re: GPL propaganda
Hyman Rosen <hyrosen@[  2008-09-25 23:23:15 
Re: GPL propaganda
chrisv <chrisv@[EMAIL   2008-09-26 07:37:42 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-26 07:57:15 
Re: GPL propaganda
Andrew Halliwell <spik  2008-09-26 14:55:04 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-26 10:32:35 
Re: GPL propaganda
Andrew Halliwell <spik  2008-09-26 17:09:58 
Re: GPL propaganda
c.c.eiftj@[EMAIL PROTECTE  2008-09-26 00:31:55 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 19:51:23 
Re: GPL propaganda
JEDIDIAH <jedi@[EMAIL   2008-09-25 20:55:31 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-09-25 22:07:42 
Re: GPL propaganda
c.c.eiftj@[EMAIL PROTECTE  2008-09-26 21:28:47 
Re: GPL propaganda
Andrew Halliwell <spik  2008-09-26 02:36:25 
Re: GPL propaganda
Hyman Rosen <hyrosen@[  2008-09-25 22:54:55 
Re: GPL propaganda
David Kastrup <dak@[EM  2008-09-26 19:27:16 
Re: GPL propaganda
Hadron <hadronquark@[E  2008-09-26 19:34:03 
Re: GPL propaganda
Kelsey Bjarnason <kels  2008-10-07 11:27:27 
Re: GPL propaganda
Rjack <user@[EMAIL PRO  2008-10-07 14:47:02 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sun Nov 23 7:56:51 CST 2008.